A pen-and-ink drawing of a magnifying glass over a subdivision plat map, enlarging one lot with a house and a lien tag.

The Title Industry from First Principles

What it is and who could win it

A $25 billion secret

Tell someone at a party that you own a title company and wait for the most awkward silence. But title is a $25 billion a year industry that upholds the integrity of the US real estate marketplace.

Title is authentication, escrow is payment

Picture this: you’re buying a concert ticket from a stranger in a parking lot. You want to know that the ticket is real, that it hasn’t been sold to someone else, and that this stranger actually owns it. Swap the ticket for a house and you have title. Does the seller actually own the house? Does anyone else hold a claim against it, like a lien or an unpaid tax? Is the person signing it over who they say they are, and not, say, a Nigerian prince? Title companies do that work, and sell a promise to make up for any damages when the authentication is wrong. That promise, by the way, paid out $667 million last year.

That promise is title insurance. Title companies also provide escrow and closing services. Think of title as authentication, and escrow and closing as payment.

Other countries like the UK and Australia have a central registry to verify ownership. America, in our own unique way, keeps property records in 3,000+ courthouses, and the title industry emerged to locate the records, read them, interpret them, and track down heirs after a death or a divorce.

Authentication in real estate is far more complex than moving the money. When you buy toilet paper on Amazon, nobody wonders whether Amazon has the right to sell it. But history shows that you certainly want to check when buying a property.

Iowa ran a social experiment

Man, sometimes I just love America. Different states do things differently, and Iowa did title very differently.

The title industry has never been the most skilled at explaining its value. Consumers are confused and feel that the cost of title insurance is frivolous. What happened in Iowa suggests that squeezing the cost is a futile effort.

In 1947, Iowa got fed up and banned title insurance outright. Later, Iowa Title Guaranty was established under the state’s housing finance agency to provide title insurance. The Iowa title insurance premium is significantly lower than those in other states provided by private underwriters. However, the Iowa title insurance can only be issued when an abstractor prepares an abstract and an attorney issues a title opinion. The E&O (errors and omissions, aka “oops”) risk shifts from title companies to attorneys. While the policy is cheaper, the cost to update the abstract and to get the attorney opinion makes up for the cost difference. Iowa swapped private underwriters for a state one, and the total fee came out similar.

So from first principles, the scope of the work is settled, and the total cost has reached equilibrium. What can change is who homebuyers choose to do the work, and how well.

Quality at scale in the last mile

Title is the last mile of a real estate transaction. Talk to title agents, and you’ll hear stories like the 72-year-old widow buying her first house after her husband’s passing, or the expecting couple setting up their starter home. Everyone wants the deal to go through, so everyone is a little on edge. It’s emotional, and there is a human element beyond sending PDFs and collecting signatures. Yet homebuyers pick a title company as an afterthought, mostly on their realtor’s recommendation: a mix of trust, inertia and (sometimes) mostly-legal joint ventures.

If you’ve been to a title conference lately, you’ve heard the pitch: AI will help the title industry to be faster, cheaper, and more efficient. Nobody on the exhibit floor was talking about the homebuyer’s experience.

Automating back office workflow seems to be the perfect match for AI’s skills. But people forget that back office cost is already compressed. The opportunity is really how to leverage AI to improve the user experience. And the users aren’t just homebuyers, but also sellers, lenders, and realtors. Where can AI boost customer experience quality at scale without taking away the one phone call that makes a homebuyer feel seen and a realtor feel supported?

What does it take to build a household name in title?

The title business has historically been built on relationships. There is no national household brand when it comes to title. The bigger players are underwriters’ direct offices and large firms affiliated with brokerages or real estate investment firms. No title firm right now has trust and relationships with homebuyers directly.

There is a firm that is perfectly positioned to come in and harvest the cashflow in title and escrow, and that is the last iBuyer standing, Opendoor.

Why Opendoor? Opendoor has homebuyers’ trust directly, plus brand awareness and attention that no local title agent can match.

Opendoor is transitioning to be a marketplace. Expanding the title business fits perfectly. When a seller comes to Opendoor for an offer, even if they don’t sell the house to Opendoor, Opendoor can sell them closing and escrow. Same for a buyer looking through Opendoor inventory.

As AI-pilled as the company is now, Opendoor can scale quality. What would it take for realtors to proactively use Opendoor for mortgage and closing? The title and escrow business then turns into part of a flywheel where all parts of Opendoor’s business start feeding off each other. A seller lists with Opendoor, buys with Opendoor, finances with Opendoor, closes with Opendoor.

Come for one, stay for all.

Five experiments I’d run to build a title business

This is the part where I pretend I work at Opendoor. If I did, I’d try:

  1. Seller’s search. If we were able to design title from scratch, title search and clearance make so much more sense sitting with the seller, perhaps bundled with the seller’s realtor fee. This smooths out the closing process, and the fee would be fairly minor.
  2. Closing timeline guarantee. Promise a closing date, and guarantee it with fee waivers.
  3. More educational content for buyers and sellers. Buyers and sellers interact with Opendoor right before they need a title company’s services.
  4. The right mix of human touches and automated updates. Some realtors like it when the title company calls their clients, white-glove style. Test automated updates against a personal call at key moments.
  5. Customized closing experience based on buyer backgrounds. Test to see how much handholding buyers really want in the closing process and what factors drive their preferences.

Dear Kaz

I’ll end with a wish. May the magic of the internet bring this essay to Kaz. The last mile of every real estate transaction deserves some sparkle.

Title is more interesting than it sounds.