Did You Know You Can Buy a Pro Hockey Team with Title Money?
How the big four started
In 2016, Bill Foley committed $500 million to bring an NHL expansion team to Las Vegas. The Vegas Golden Knights began play in 2017 and won the Stanley Cup in 2023. In 2022, his Black Knight Football Club group bought a controlling stake in Premier League club AFC Bournemouth. In June 2026, he launched a bid for an NBA expansion team. Behind much of that business success sits a title insurance company: Fidelity National.
I find this so fascinating since title insurance is an industry of old companies. All four companies trace their roots back more than a century. So what did Bill Foley do differently?
A little history
Before title insurance came about, the law said buyer beware. There was no solid mechanism to combat forged deeds, missing heirs, unrecorded sales, and conflicting surveys. An 1868 Philadelphia case, Watson v. Muirhead, shows how harsh this could be. A conveyancer searching a title found a lien against the property. Relying on an attorney’s opinion, he treated it as invalid. It wasn’t. The court ruled he wasn’t liable, because he had acted with reasonable care. The buyer had to eat the loss.
That left buyers exposed. Buyers needed someone to stand behind the search with money. In 1876, Philadelphia answered with the first title insurance company. The idea was simple: do the search, then guarantee it. Title insurance was born.
The big four
Each of the big four began the same way: lots of properties changed hands, and buyers wanted protection.
Fidelity: the Gold Rush (1848). As gold pulled fortune seekers to San Francisco in 1848, a notary named C.V. Gillespie started a business searching property records. Everyone wanted land, and nobody trusted anyone’s paper. His records business was the seed of Western Title Insurance Company, which formed in 1920. Fidelity National Title acquired Western Title in 1987.
Stewart: the hurricane (1893). Maco Stewart, a young attorney, decided to build one reliable repository of Galveston County’s real estate records. Seven years later, the 1900 hurricane leveled Galveston. Thousands died. As Stewart tells its own history, the official records were lost, while Stewart’s sat safe in a fireproof vault and became the basis for rebuilding the city’s property lines. Imagine being the person whose filing cabinet saved a city.
First American: a brand-new county (1894). In 1889, Orange County split off from Los Angeles County. A new county meant new deeds, new boundaries, and new records to manage on its own. Two small abstract firms, First American’s predecessors, opened to serve the real estate boom, and they competed.
In 1894, a local businessman named C.E. Parker merged them into one: the Orange County Title Company. He became its first president. His family would steer the business for more than a century.
Old Republic: the Minneapolis syndicate (1907). In August 1907, a group of prominent Minneapolis businessmen and real estate experts pooled their money and formed the Real Estate Title Insurance Company to protect owners from losses tied to title defects.
It grew quietly for two decades and earned a reputation for accuracy across the upper Midwest. In 1928, it renamed itself the Title Insurance Company of Minnesota (Minnesota Title). In 1929, it crossed $1 million in assets. Old Republic, which had other insurance lines outside of title, bought it in 1978.
The re-founding of Fidelity National
While all four companies can trace their roots back more than a century, Fidelity’s market dominance is more of an exception.
In 1980, Fidelity National Title Insurance Company was a small underwriter that had started in Nebraska in 1961. It bought the assets of an even smaller underwriter in Tucson, Arizona. That deal brought a corporate lawyer named Bill Foley and his partner, Frank Willey, into the picture.
Fidelity was a regional company, not one of the top 40 title insurers, with about $6 million in revenue. In 1984, Foley and Willey formed a holding company, Fidelity National Financial, and took control of the insurer in a leveraged buyout worth about $21 million. Then they changed how it ran.
They relied less on independent agencies. Fidelity used both company-owned operations and independent agents. But it leaned on its own direct operations, which gave it a closer watch on costs and on the policies it wrote.
They made employees owners. In 1985, Fidelity sold stock to its employees. Its own history calls it the nation’s first employee-owned title underwriter. The company ran on five precepts: bias for action, autonomy and entrepreneurship, close customer relationships, minimal bureaucracy, and employee ownership. Those are rare words in a slow industry.
They stayed profitable when others didn’t. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, real estate slumped nationwide, and California was hit especially hard. Fidelity kept posting profits anyway. In 1991, its revenue reached $220.6 million. A 1992 California Business report put its claims at 6.7% of earned premiums, the lowest in the industry that year.
Then they bought. Fidelity went public in 1987 and started acquiring. Over about 20 years, it made more than 80 deals. Buying Nations Title in 1996 made it the fourth-largest underwriter in the country.
In 2000 came the boldest move. Fidelity bought Chicago Title, which had already acquired Ticor Title and Security Union. Chicago Title was the bigger company, and Fidelity borrowed money and spent its cash reserves to do it. The deal, valued at more than $1 billion, made Fidelity the largest title insurer in the country, with about 30% of the market.
Then came 2008. As the financial crisis crushed the industry, LandAmerica Financial Group entered bankruptcy proceedings. Fidelity bought its two main underwriters, Commonwealth Land Title and Lawyers Title, for a final price of about $235 million. Foley called it a historic opportunity. Based on 2007 figures, the combined company held about 46% of the market on a pro forma basis.
That business acumen has me in awe.
Who is next?
Foley’s story shows that a business-savvy team with a plan and conviction can still reshape the industry. His edge came from three things: operational discipline, strategic acquisitions, and the consolidation of local businesses into a national platform. Holding it together were disciplined execution and incentives that aligned employees with the business.
I wonder who will be the next person to buy a pro sports team with title money.